Post Edit Home Help

Key Pages

Joukowsky Institute Classroom |
Islamic Archaeology 2006 |
Islamic Landscapes 2006 |
Islamic Archaeology 2007

Changes [Dec 11, 2007]

qala' (citadel)
ar-Raqqa/ar-Rafiqa
Quseir/Qusayr
umma
the three routes (1...
al-Qahira
thaghr/thughur
   More Changes...
Changes [Dec 11, 2007]: qala' (citadel), ar-Raqqa/ar-Rafiqa, Quseir/Qusayr, umma, ... MORE

Find Pages

Posted at Oct 14/2007 06:52PM:

Sebastian Gallese: Pirenne Thesis

Put forth by the Belgian historian Henri Pirenne in Mohammed and Charlemagne (1935).

"Without Mohammed, Charlemagne would indeed have been inconceivable."

Details:

1. Western Europe Before Islam (4th-6th Century CE)

2. Islam and the Carolingians (7th-8th Century CE)

Conclusion: "Changes in the Mediterranean isolated the Merovingian king in the north-west Europe and caused the gradual rise of the Carolingians." The Pope allied with the economically powerful Carolingians and "ultimately led to the coronation of Charlemagne" and the "Empire of the West" and the end of the classical world in the seventh century.

In class we looked at how Hodges & Whitehouse conclude that the Pirenne Thesis is correct; however, Charlemagne did not reach power directly from the Muslim conquest of Byzantium, but from Muslim silver traded through the Baltic (Vikings).

From Mohammed, Charlemagne & the Origins of Europe by Hodges & Whitehouse Pp 3,4


Posted at Oct 15/2007 03:28PM:
Ian: Given that Pirenne establishes this historical link which H&W revise, what has this meant for the way in which scholars might approach the archaeology of the Muslim world? Certainly one of the significant features of this thesis is that it has pushed academics to consider that the Muslim world has had an effect on the development of the West. The question is whether it has really captured the nature of that dynamic relationship or only given it lipservice.
Edit this Page - Attach File - Add Image - References - Print
Page last modified by Ian Mon Oct 15/2007 15:28
You must signin to post comments.
Site Home > The Joukowsky Institute for Archaeology Classroom > Islamic Archaeology Glossary 2007 > Pirenne Thesis